Comparent
UnregulatedCity

Short-Term Rental Regulations
in Fire Island Pines, NY

Last verified: March 2026 · Report an update

Zoning & Conditions

The Town of Brookhaven defines 'transient residential occupancy' as non-owner-occupied rentals for less than 28 nights but explicitly excludes Fire Island from this definition. While local town registration is not required for Fire Island Pines, Suffolk County imposes a hotel/motel occupancy tax on stays under 30 days, and New York State requires booking services to report rental stays.

Official Resources

Official Fire Island Pines STR regulation source

Frequently Asked Questions

Are short-term rentals allowed in Fire Island Pines, NY?
The Town of Brookhaven defines 'transient residential occupancy' as non-owner-occupied rentals for less than 28 nights but explicitly excludes Fire Island from this definition. While local town registration is not required for Fire Island Pines, Suffolk County imposes a hotel/motel occupancy tax on stays under 30 days, and New York State requires booking services to report rental stays.
Is a permit required to operate a short-term rental in Fire Island Pines?
No permit is currently required to operate a short-term rental in Fire Island Pines.
Comparent

Looking for property managers in Fire Island Pines, NY?

Compare top-rated short-term rental managers on Comparent — read reviews, see pricing, and find the right fit.

View Property Managers

Disclaimer

This information is for general reference only and may not reflect the most current regulations. STR regulations change frequently. Always verify requirements with official local government sources before operating a short-term rental.

Last verified: March 2026 · Suggest a correction